Is there anything more annoying than a mascara meltdown on a steamy day or after a dip in the pool? This is the moment when you realize water-resistant mascara is not optional but essential. To find out which formulas won’t break down despite the elements, we asked the pros to pick their top wands. Scroll below to see the best waterproof mascaras.
1. Maybelline Lash Discovery Mini-Brush Waterproof Mascara
“I am crazy about the tiny brush. Not only can you coat every single hair, but it doesn’t get clumpy during application so you have long, full lashes that won’t run or smear.” —Fiona Stiles, makeup artist
“I love that it comes in a brownish-black shade and dries really fast so it seals in the curl of your lashes. It’s the only one I use!” —Kate Lee, Chanel makeup artist
“It stays on yet it’s also easy to take off which is super important because a lot of waterproof mascaras can be really harsh on the lashes.” —Molly Stern, makeup artist
“The name says it all—this mascara is like artillery for the eyes, and literally doesn’t move! It’s my all time favorite summer-proof mascara.” —Tim Quinn, Celebrity Face Director and National Director of Creative Artistry for Giorgio Armani Beauty
5. Dior Diorshow Iconic Extreme Waterproof
“Most waterproof formulas are hard to layer on and leaves lashes brittle. This has lots of conditioning agents to help prevent the ‘stiff lash’ and the tiered brush allows you to comb the mascara through the lashes to prevent clumping. I’ve even used it for a 12-hour underwater photo shoot! You’ll need to use makeup remover that will break down the mascara—but not break your lashes. In a pinch Vaseline or baby oil works well.” —Ricky Wilson, makeup artist
6. Clinique Lash Power Mascara
“I love the tiny brush because it’s perfect for a precise application on top and bottom lashes. It’s not technically waterproof but it stays on like it is and won’t smudge. It’s the best of both worlds as far as mascara goes because at the end of the day, it’s easily removed by just warm water. ” —Nick Barose, makeup artist
“It doesn’t smudge—at all!—and holds a curl. When it’s time to take it off, I find that Lancôme Bi-Facil removes it in a snap.”—Melanie Inglessis, makeup artist
“It stays on through tears, rain and is impossible to take off without waterproof makeup remover.” —Linda Andersson, makeup artist
